New Era 59FIFTY vs Richardson: Which Cap
New Era 59FIFTY vs Richardson pits two very different silhouettes: the 59FIFTY is a structured, flat-brim fitted cap, while Richardson’s signature 112 is an adjustable, mesh-back trucker. Speedy Pros Hats, family-owned in Brandon, FL since 2009, customizes both with no minimums and a free digital proof.
This is a style and fit choice more than a quality one. The 59FIFTY is a premium, sized, flat-brim cap with a full-fabric back, the look of streetwear and on-field sports. The Richardson 112 is a mid-profile trucker with a mesh back and an adjustable snapback, the look of teams, crews, and companies. Pick the one that fits your brand’s vibe and your order.
Speedy Pros Hats, a family-owned custom hat company serving the Tampa Bay area, has decorated hundreds of thousands of caps for teams, businesses, and events over more than 15 years. Every hat is decorated here in the USA, any order size is welcome, and free artwork setup is included on orders of 12 or more.
- New Era 59FIFTY. Fitted, flat-brim, full-fabric back.
- Richardson 112. Adjustable mesh-back trucker.
- Fit split. Sized 59FIFTY vs one-size trucker.
- Proof before production. You approve the logo and colors on a free digital proof.
59FIFTY vs Richardson: The Short Answer
Choose the New Era 59FIFTY for a premium, fitted, flat-brim look with a full-fabric back, the streetwear and on-field icon. It is sized to the head, so it wears tailored, and the firm front shows a logo crisply. See the 59FIFTY review for detail.
Choose the Richardson 112 for the classic mesh-back trucker, mid-profile, adjustable, and instantly recognizable on teams and crews. It is one size, so it skips sizing, and the structured front brands cleanly. Our Richardson buying guide covers the range.
The real differences are back style (full fabric vs mesh), brim (flat vs pre-curved), and fit (sized vs adjustable). Both hold a logo well. If your brand leans premium and streetwear, lean 59FIFTY; if it leans team, trade, or classic trucker, lean Richardson. Our fitted vs snapback guide covers the New Era side.
59FIFTY vs Richardson at a Glance
Here is how the two caps compare.
| New Era 59FIFTY | Richardson 112 | |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Fitted flat-brim | Mesh-back trucker |
| Back | Full fabric | Mesh |
| Brim | Flat | Pre-curved |
| Fit | Sized to the head | Adjustable, one size |
| Vibe | Premium, streetwear | Team, trade, classic |
The 59FIFTY is a fitted, flat-brim cap with a full-fabric back; the Richardson 112 is an adjustable, pre-curved mesh-back trucker. Both brand a logo cleanly.
If you want the premium fitted icon, the 59FIFTY is the pick; if you want the classic adjustable trucker, the Richardson 112 is the pick. For the adjustable New Era look, see our 9FIFTY guide; for the trucker range, our trucker hats buying guide.
Fit and Setting Decide It
The two caps suit different settings. The 59FIFTY’s fitted, flat-brim look reads premium and modern, at home on a merch drop or a streetwear brand, but it is sized, so a group order needs head sizes. The Richardson 112’s adjustable trucker is the workhorse for teams, crews, and companies, one size, easy to order in bulk, and endlessly recognizable. Match the cap to where it will be worn. Our size chart helps if you go fitted.
Both hold a logo crisply on firm fronts. You can customize the 59FIFTY through our custom New Era range or the 112 through our custom Richardson range, and we proof either first. Start at the quick order page.
Branding Either Cap
Both caps give you a firm front for a crisp, centered embroidered logo. We digitize your art and size it on your proof either way.
A patch or 3D puff works on both. The 59FIFTY’s flat brim leaves room for a visor wordmark; the 112’s pre-curved trucker keeps a classic centered look.
Thread and patch color set the tone on either cap. Whichever you pick, everything is locked on your free proof before we run it.
Let the setting choose. Streetwear or merch drop with room to gather sizes points to the fitted 59FIFTY. A team, crew, or bulk order that needs one size points to the Richardson 112 trucker.
Who Picks the 59FIFTY vs Richardson
Brands and shops with a premium or streetwear feel, and the room to gather sizes, tend to pick the 59FIFTY. Teams, crews, and companies that want a one-size, recognizable trucker tend to pick the Richardson 112. Both are quality caps we customize daily.
If you are weighing brands more broadly, our Flexfit vs New Era and Richardson vs Yupoong guides add context, and are New Era hats true to size covers 59FIFTY sizing.
Whichever you choose, one logo covers the run, and we proof it first so the cap matches your brand.
How to Order a Custom 59FIFTY or Richardson Cap
Pick your cap and colors, add sizes if you go fitted, send your logo, and approve the free digital proof. There are no minimums, with free artwork setup on orders of 12 or more, and every cap is decorated in the USA.
Browse our custom New Era or custom Richardson caps, or start a custom order and we will proof it first. Pricing and the production window are shown on the quick order page.
Ordering fitted for a bulk crew. The 59FIFTY is sized, so a large crew order means collecting head sizes. If you want one-size simplicity for a team, the adjustable Richardson 112 is the easier pick.
What to Send and What You Get
Send your logo as a vector file when you can — an AI, EPS, or PDF — and we set it up for decoration. A high-resolution PNG works too, and if the art needs cleanup we handle it. Free artwork setup is included on orders of 12 or more, so most orders start with no setup cost at all.
We match your brand colors on the free digital proof, where you see the cap and the logo together before anything is made. Nothing goes into production until you approve that proof, so the first New Era 59FIFTY or Richardson hats off the line is the one you signed off on — colors, size, and placement included.
Reordering is simple. Your setup stays on file, so a repeat run comes back consistent with the first. With no minimums you can start with a single piece or a small batch to confirm the look, then scale up once the design is proven, all from the same shop and the same quick order page.
Every order includes that free proof and our help getting the art right, so you are never guessing at the result. If something is off on our end, we make it right or remake the order on a production error — that is the whole point of proofing before production, to catch anything before a hat is made rather than after.
Why Order Custom 59FIFTY and Richardson Hats From Speedy Pros Hats
We are a family-owned custom hat company in Brandon, FL, decorating hats for the Tampa Bay area and customers nationwide since 2009. Over more than 15 years we have stitched hundreds of thousands of caps, and we hold a 4.9 out of 5 rating across more than 23,000 reviews.
Every order is decorated in the USA with no minimums, so you can test one cap or outfit a whole organization. You get a free digital proof before production, and free artwork setup is included on orders of 12 or more. Pricing and the current production window are shown on the quick order page, and if we make a production error, we make it right.
Is the New Era 59FIFTY or Richardson better for custom hats?
Neither is better overall; they are different silhouettes. The 59FIFTY is a fitted, flat-brim icon; the Richardson 112 is an adjustable mesh-back trucker. Pick by look, fit, and setting.
What is the main difference?
Back, brim, and fit. The 59FIFTY has a full-fabric back, flat brim, and sized fit; the Richardson 112 has a mesh back, pre-curved brim, and adjustable one-size fit.
Which is easier for a group order?
The Richardson 112 is one size, so it skips sizing. The 59FIFTY is fitted and needs head sizes, so it takes more planning for a group.
Do both take a logo well?
Yes. Both use firm, structured fronts, so a centered embroidered logo, a patch, or 3D puff reads crisp on either cap.
Do you have a minimum?
No. Order a single cap or a full run of either. Free artwork setup is included on orders of 12 or more.
Can you match my brand colors?
Yes. We match thread and, where possible, cap colors to your brand, and you approve it on a free digital proof before production.
Are both decorated in the USA?
Yes. Every cap is decorated in the USA, with a free digital proof before we run it.
The fitted flat-brim icon or the classic trucker, both branded crisp.
Popular blank: Richardson 112 Snapback Trucker.
Related blanks: New Era 59FIFTY Fitted.
★★★★★ 4.9/5 · 23,000+ reviews · Made in the USA
Decorated in the USA, no minimums, free digital proof. Nearby reads: New Era 59FIFTY review and Richardson vs Yupoong.
Related guides: New Era 59FIFTY or New Era 9FIFTY, New Era vs Richardson, '47 vs New Era and New Era 39THIRTY or 59FIFTY, otto vs new era, new era vs yupoong.